A couple
days ago, essayist Miriam Elman published a piece about Jerusalem Day (“Five
Reasons to Celebrate Jerusalem Day”, Legal Insurrection, May 15, 2015).
I’d like you to look at it. It makes a proper companion piece to the essay following,
below.
I have
edited/rewritten parts of this essay to fit my format:
The newest
addition to the Jewish calendar is Yom Yirushalayim, Jerusalem Day. It’s held on
the 28th day of the Hebrew month of Iyar—six weeks after the Passover seder and
one week before the eve of the holiday of Shavuot. This year, 2015, the 28th of Iyar falls on Sunday, May 17.
In June
1967, 28 Iyar was the third day of the Six Day War. On that day, Jerusalem
was reunified as Israel’s capital city.
It’s the day we now call, Yom Yerushalayim—Jerusalem Day. It’s the day when, 48 years
ago, Jewish fighting forces brought Jerusalem “back to Jewish sovereignty”.
To celebrate
this day, thousands of Israelis head to the city. They go to dance in the
streets. They go for the annual ’Flag
Parade’.
But as MyJewishLearning
notes, Yom Yerushalayim can make some politically liberal Jews uncomfortable. For
them, the city is too controversial.
It’s a
shame. Jerusalem Day deserves to be celebrated with pride and joy—openly and
without reservation.
Why
Celebrate Jerusalem Day? Here are five reasons:
REASON #1: Jewish holy places are liberated
from an illegal Jordanian occupation.
In 1949
Jordan ethnically cleansed every last Jew from the ancient Jewish Quarter of
the Old City.
Then, in a
shameless violation of the April 1949 truce agreement, for nearly two decades Jordan
denied Jews the right to worship at the Western Wall.
The
restrictions against the Jews were so severe that tourists who wanted to cross
over from west Jerusalem into the Jordanian-controlled part of the city had to
produce a baptismal certificate.
REASON #2: The whole city of Jerusalem
is reclaimed and reunited under Israeli sovereignty.
On June 7,
1967, the third day of the Six Day War, the 55th Paratroopers Brigade received
the order to take the Old City. They succeeded. In theory, Jews are no longer
restricted. Neither are Arabs.
REASON #3: Jewish Jerusalem is reconstituted.
The Jordanian
authorities spent their nineteen year rule looting, ransacking, befouling, and
dynamiting every last vestige of Jewish heritage.
As Marshall
J. Breger of the Columbus School of Law, Catholic University of America and
co-author of a seminal study on the city describes: twenty-seven synagogues and
some thirty schools were damaged or destroyed. The Porath Yosef, Hurva, and
Tiferet Israel synagogues were destroyed. The famous Yohanan ben Zakkai
Synagogue was devastated from within and survived only as a shell. The
synagogue founded by the great biblical scholar Nachmanides in 1267 was devastated…the hallowed Jewish cemetery on
the Mount of Olives suffered a similar fate…Graves ripped open, and bones
scattered; thousands of tombstones smashed or removed by the Jordanian army to
build fortifications, footpaths, army camps, and latrines…The Jewish Quarter
was so thoroughly destroyed, according to news reporters, that it had the look
of Stalingrad or Berlin in World War II”.
Israel’s
been restoring these Jewish heritage sites since 1967.
REASON #4: Jewish faithful can now, in theory, visit the Temple Mount.
Jewish
visits to the Temple Mount have increased by 92% since 2009. According to new
figures released in January, 10,906 Jews ascended the Temple Mount in 2014, up
28% from the 8,528 who visited the site in 2013.
It’s
something that a number of rabbinic authorities see as the Jewish people’s
“spiritual awakening, and reconnecting—not only to their most holy site, but to
their own destiny”.
Jews still cannot pray on the Temple Mount. But with the Mount in Jewish hands, that day will come.
Jews still cannot pray on the Temple Mount. But with the Mount in Jewish hands, that day will come.
REASON #5: It Reaffirms the Jewish connection to
the holy city and to the land.
For nearly a
century, Arab Muslims have belittled, denied and denigrated Jerusalem’s Jewish
past. As noted by scholar Yitzhak Reiter, who has extensively researched the
contemporary Muslim denial of the Jewish Temple and Western Wall: Islamic
nationalists, be they clerics, academics or politicians, seek to refute claims
regarding Jerusalem’s centrality to Judaism; they deny the Jewish Temple’s
existence in Jerusalem and assert that the Western Wall is not an authentic
remnant of the Temple’s external supporting wall…the Arab-Muslim meta-narrative
tries to deny any serious or long-lasting connection of Jews and Judaism to
Jerusalem and the land. Yom Yerushalayim
reminds the world that, despite the Arab attempts to re-write history, Jerusalem
is ‘Jewish’.
This Day
reminds us of the basic truths of Jewish heritage: Jerusalem is intimately
connected to the history of the Jewish people. It's the Day we celebrate that
history. It's the Day we assert our sovereign legitimacy over the Jewish eternal
capital city, Jerusalem.
--
My comment:
the original is better than my summary/rewrite. But this summary and the
original represent a good introduction to the essay immediately below, entitled,
“Jerusalem Day and a parade Israel’s Leftists hate”.
No comments:
Post a Comment