Israel
headlines tell a story. They tell you the news. But sometimes, they reveal some
underlying truths.
Return to
this blog every Tuesday and Friday after Noon. You’ll see a sampling of headlines
from Israel’s press—and some comments about those headlines.
Today’s headlines—and
those comments--come from November 15 - 18, 2013.
The Arab-Israel
conflict
-
Teen Terrorist: I Intended to
Stab a Soldier
- Hamas to PA: Stop Peace Talks,
They're US Dictates
-'Hot Mic'
Catches UN Disbelief at Anti-Israel Bias
-Netanyahu:
Outspoken UN interpreter can work here anytime
-PA Trend:
Naming Soccer Teams After Terrorists
-Report:
Israel, Saudi Arabia Plan Iran Strike
-PA
Official: No Peace with Current Coalition
-Netanyahu:
Palestinians need to make concessions in peace talks as well
-Hamas shows
off ‘terror tunnels’ on anniversary of IDF operation
-Ya'alon:
Escalation in West Bank due to diplomatic process
- Fatah: 'Settlements' a 'Crime Against
Humanity'
- PA pays former prisoners
$10,000-$50,000 upon release
-Hamas:
Ceasefire is Time to Prepare the Tunnels
-Hollande
Meets Abbas, Attacks 'Settlements'
-Netanyahu
invites Abbas to Knesset for sake of peace
-In
Ramallah, Hollande urges Palestinians to be flexible on right of return
-PA: No
Peace Without Full 'Right of Return'
America and Israel
- John McCain: Kerry a 'Human Wrecking
Ball' in Middle East
- McCain: We've Lost Influence in the Middle
East
-Obama to
Congress: You Want War? Then Toughen the Sanctions
-Obama
Refuses to Speak to Netanyahu
-Israelis
not thrilled with US foreign policy
-The current
Israel-US rift was only a matter of time
-‘It seems
like Barack Obama has no red lines’
-Pollard’s
operator: U.S. promised to free spy after 10 years
-Putin
controls Middle East
Iran
- Iranian: No Progress if Our Nuclear
Rights are Ignored
- Poll: Most Israelis Believe IDF Can
Strike Iran On Its Own
-Binyamin
Netanyahu's stance in disagreement with the United States
-Zarif: We
Won't Give Up Our Right to Enrich
-PM: Iran’s
nuclear drive ‘directly threatens Israel’s future’
-McCain:
Don't increase sanctions on Iran this year
-Likud MK:
Western powers too eager to strike deal with Iran
-Netanyahu:
Deal offered to Iran lets it acquire fissile material for nuke within 3 weeks
- Netanyahu: P5+1 Offering Iran
'Enormous Bonus’
-Netanyahu:
A good deal strips Iran of ability to make fissile material for nuclear bomb
-Netanyahu:
It's my duty to prevent a second Holocaust against the Jewish people
- Ya'alon:
Iranian regime dreams of defeating west
- Netanyahu
to CNN: Bad Iran deal could lead to war
-‘Geneva
talks a facade, US-Iran worked secretly on deal for past year’
Life in
Israel
-Israel second
in Global Dynamism Index technology sector
-Apple
reportedly buying Israel’s PrimeSense for $345 million.
-Can-Fite to
list on NYSE MKT
-Israeli
agritech firm promising growth in crop yields
-OECD:
Israel is the only member that cut spending per capita 2001-2011
-BGU,
Chinese firm to create desert research institute in Mongolia
Israel
politics
-Minister
says coalition will collapse over peace talks ‘sooner or later’
-Minister
Peri: Israel must be careful not to exacerbate row with US
-Peri: Palestinian
issue will tear cabinet apart
-Labor chief
Yacimovich assails Netanyahu for 'slapping Americans in face'
- PM Appoints Liberman to Take Over
While he's in Moscow
The Arab
Middle East
-Libya Reels
as Tripoli Violence Continues
- Sources:
Deputy Libyan intelligence chief kidnapped
-Gunmen kill
senior security officer in Cairo
-Syrian
troops launch offensive near Lebanon border
- Thousands
of Syrian refugees flood into Lebanon
-Kuwait
mulls screening workers for homosexuality
-Gaza Strip
full of corrupt millionaires, says Palestinian official.
- Gazan 'Arab Idol' Attacks Israel on
US Tour
The
Temple Mount
--Arabs Wave
PLO Flags on Temple Mount
The war of
the Left against Israel
-Judea-Samaria
Conference to Begin Amid Leftist Threats
Jews
around the world
-'Apartheid
Week' Approved at University of Toronto, Scarsborough
-Simon
Weisenthal Center Exposes European anti-Semitism
-Brooklyn:
Anti-Semitic Attacks Continue in 'Game' to Hurt Jews
--Simon
Wiesenthal Center Condemns Toronto Univ. Apartheid Week
-Italian
police raid homes of suspected online anti-Semites
-Norweigan
FM Brende applauds Kerry's Israel-Palestine and Iran efforts
-Norwegian
Jews hoping new circumcision rules head off ban
-------
There’s a
lot to write about in today’s news cycle: Iran, French President Francois Hollande,
Mahmoud Abbas, Norwegian Jews and Israel’s business environment are just a few of the story lines we could talk about. I’ve only got
space to tell you about three of these stories. For the others, you’ll have to
look again at the headlines and deduce what's up.
Iran
dominated the first part of this news cycle. The West, led by the US, promised
it could get Iran to back away from pursuing nuclear weapons. The deal was, if Iran stopped its march to a nuclear
arsenal (that’s how the agreement was described in the press), the West would
lift what have become crushing economic sanctions.
It was
supposed to be a good deal for all involved: Iran would get billions of dollars
released from ‘sanction’. The West would get peace. Israel would get peace of
mind.
The US loved
the deal. It began to leak stories of an impending agreement. But then Israel objected.
It made a series of announcements about the agreement: it was, Israel said, a
bad deal.
Immediately,
a highly-publicized argument broke out between the US and Israel. Through headlines,
both sides barked at the other. It was like watching a couple’s marriage break
up in public.
Is Israel’s
love-affair with the US at an end? Certainly, Israel’s Left got frightened. It cried that Israel
shouldn’t slap the US in the face.
Is that what
Israel was doing?
Anger filled
the headlines. A shortened version of this fight goes something like this: US Secretary of State John Kerry talked about an impending agreement with Iran. Israel said it didn't like what it saw. Netanyahu criticized the deal. Kerry said that if Netanyahu was
criticizing this agreement, he was out of touch; he hasn’t been properly informed. Netanyahu
fired back: I’m totally up-to-date; I’m completely informed; this deal is bad.
Then the
deal collapsed. The US blamed Iran. Iran blamed the US. Israel and the US
couldn’t see eye-to-eye. Everybody saw raw nerves exposed by both the US and Israel.
Israel urged
the US Congress not to lift sanctions. Israel wanted Congress to toughen
sanctions. US President Obama responded, you want war? Then toughen the sanctions.
Iran
declared that the US was afraid of war. The Iranians appeared to suggest that
the US would do anything to avoid a confrontation with someone bold enough to threaten
it.
Iran even suggested that Obama had smoked marijuana when he was twenty—as if that
explained something about Obama.
This was
getting ugly.
US Senator
John McCain got into the act. A former soldier, he knew all about war, power
and force. So he announced that the collapse of the Iran talks was just one of
a string of diplomatic failures that illustrate how the US has lost its power
to influence; then he called Kerry a human wrecking ball.
Then he
said, the US shouldn’t increase sanctions this year.
Netanyahu
announced that the deal the West had offered was so bad, it would allow Iran to
acquire fissile [sic] material for a nuke within 3 weeks. It’s a deal that would, he
suggested, lead to war.
President
Obama—according to some Israel headlines—got so angry at Netanyahu that he stopped
talking to him. He refused to take calls from Netanyahu.
If the Israeli Prime Minister wanted to say
something, he could say it to Kerry.
Nice guy,
the US President.
France,
meanwhile, became a hero. Turns out that the US didn’t scuttle the talks. Neither did Iran. It was
France. France felt that—hold on to your hat—the deal was bad. It was ugly. It
wouldn’t do anything to curb Iran’s nuclear ambitions.
How does
that make Kerry and Obama look? More important, what does the French action
here tell Israelis about the US?
An Israeli
poll taken during this ‘fight’ had the answer: Israelis didn’t believe the US.
French
President Francois Hollande became an instant hero in Israel. A scheduled trip
to Israel became a celebration.
It was fun.
But it didn’t last. As part of his tour here, Hollande went to Ramallah. He went carrying a gift of 10 million euros
for the ‘Palestinians’. He also gave Abbas another gift: he announced that
Israel must end all ‘settlements’.
Oopps. Hollande’s
value as a hero plummeted.
Hollande is
scheduled to return to Jerusalem after his confab with Abbas. His return will
be interesting.
Before he
left for Ramallah, Hollande heard Netanyahu speak to the Knesset (in Hollande’s
honour). In his speech, Netanyahu made a public offer to Abbas: come to our
Knesset. Tell us that you accept Israel as the Jewish State and we will give
you peace.
We may never
know what these words meant to Hollande, for when he went to Ramallah, he was
not reported to have repeated these words in public. Instead, he was reported
as saying, all ‘settlements’ should end. Then he added something new: Abbas needed
to be ‘flexible’ on the ‘refugee’ question.
Interesting. One of the
main Palestinian Authority (PA) negotiating points for any ‘peace’ talks with
Israel has always been the ‘return’ of all ‘refugees’ who fled Israel in 1948.
At that time, some 500,000 – 800,000 Arabs (the number you use depends upon
whom you believe) fled Israel. These refugees represent the only refugees of
that period (after World War Two) who have never been integrated into or
absorbed into a new life in a new place. By contrast, some 700,000-800,000 Jews
were themselves expelled from or compelled to leave Arab countries in the decade after 1948.
All of them have been absorbed by other nations, primarily Israel. There is no
‘Jewish’ refugee problem.
These Arabs,
however, haven’t been absorbed. They have been cooped up in squalid ‘refugee
camps’.
Is it
politically correct to say that their squalor has been managed and maintained
by the United Nations?
Now, through
birth, these Arabs add up to some 5 million people. Abbas wants them to
‘return’ to Israel as part of any final agreement.
That creates
a problem. Currently, Israel has perhaps 7.7 million people. Six million are
Jews. App 1.6 million are Arab. Israel understands what will happen if,
suddenly, there were an additional 5 million (unemployed) Arabs moving into
Israel. It would be the end of the Jewish State.
Abbas, for
his part, doesn’t want these 5 million Arabs, either. He doesn’t want them in
his new ‘Palestine’. Yes, he claims they are his ‘people’. He claims he fights
for them. But he rejects them. He has already stated that no ‘refugees’ will be
allowed to enter ‘Palestine’. They must stay in their squalor until they ‘return’
to Israel.
Aren’t they
good enough for him?
Some observers
of the Arab world feel that, should Abbas accept anything less than a full
‘return’, he will be assassinated. The Arabs have been teaching too many
children for too long that they are destined to ‘return’. Compromise on this
‘question’ is not an option. The Arab
culture in the PA simply won’t allow it.
At 4:30 pm Monday, November 18, 2013, one news
outlet headlined that Hollande had recommended to Abbas to be ‘flexible’ on the
refugee issue. Less than two hours later, at 6:14 pm, that news outlet
headlined Abbas’ response: no peace without full right of return.
In
international politics, that kind of unequivocal response—given so quickly--is
the equivalent of a bare-knuckles punch in the face. It will be instructive to
see how Hollande talks about Abbas’ aggressiveness when he (Hollande) returns to
Jerusalem.
Will he do
as the EU has done—and ignore it? Or, will he step up—as he did with Iran—and
confront it for what it is—a deal-killing demand that no rational nation
anywhere could accept.
One wonders: while in Ramallah, did Hollande see the new Fatah logo? It shows a map of the new 'Palestine' replacing Israel. If he saw that picture, would Hollande declare that France would never support that kind of 'peace'?
One wonders: while in Ramallah, did Hollande see the new Fatah logo? It shows a map of the new 'Palestine' replacing Israel. If he saw that picture, would Hollande declare that France would never support that kind of 'peace'?
Abbas,
meanwhile, is in fighting form. He airs his hate of Israel with an almost jaunty spirit: he used this news cycle to name soccer teams after Jew-killers and to declare that, if
Israel wants peace, it will have to change its governing coalition.
Nice guy.
Take a look
at the other headlines. They tell their
own stories. Some combine to form their own story lines. Can you find them?
No comments:
Post a Comment